In my mid-twenties, after returning home from work, the janitor of the building complex I lived in asked me to call the police immediately as my mother had just been run over and was in hospital. After some frantic searches around public hospitals, I found her and learned she was clinically fine, but the shock of this experience led me to visit days later the exact location where she was hit by a motorcycle early evening. From this informal ‘inspection’ and conversations with residents and business owners, I learned that road accidents involving pedestrians occurred frequently at this intersection; however, no structural measures had been taken to mitigate these known risks. This experience then left me wondering i) What if I could share the risks, and evidence, of this intersection with a large audience in an easy, safe, and trusted way? What if I could learn what had happened before and monitor the structural and nonstructural measures taken by local officials -- and residents -- to mitigate these risks? How about creating something like this SenseCityVity project?
Ten years later, a toddler in Queensland died after being neglected and abused. That piece of news ‘hit me’ very hard as I had just become a father the year before. Pondering on what I could do to help this vulnerable group, as well as caretakers, I put together a research proposal to develop a mobile application that would collect ‘perceived risk inputs’ and provide, as a ‘weighted probabilistic output’, a set of recommendations for prevention and early intervention. Unfortunately, I have never had a chance to pursue this project titled: ‘Reducing the Cost Error of False Risks with Artificial Intelligence’. The main takeaway from this unrealized project was leading my curiosity to the field -- and potentials -- of artificial intelligence in the context of Error Management Theory so that I could incorporate those learnings into my future research projects.
I wrote the research proposal on child maltreatment because around that same time I was looking into the inherent and residual risks associated with the 2010/2011 Queensland Floods for my doctoral thesis. During my initial investigations on the early signs of this evolving risk, I came across a post shared in a forum from a concerned citizen urging residents living downstream the Brisbane River to evacuate due to the imminent water release from the Wivenhoe Dam. I became particularly interested in this message as it was uploaded days before the release of the official warning by authorities. As the underlying themes of my dissertation were risk perception and decision making, I could not stop wondering whether the number of deaths and missing victims would have been different, despite hindsight bias and related ‘behavioral traps’, had this post reached the people it needed to. How could this online forum have ensured that such an individual is reputable and trustworthy? How could this individual increase the trustworthiness of the piece of information he/she was sharing online? How could at-risk communities be informed about an emerging threat by an outlier? How could such an outlier be ‘intelligently’ validated through an automated classification and ranking system? This set of questions led me to explore the possibilities that heuristics, or rules of thumb, and networks create for informing individual risk perception and shaping decision making under uncertainty, which I later included in my thesis and served for my assessment on the role of eyewitnesses in spurring collective action during the COVID-19 pandemic titled: ‘Powering Social Media: Simple Guide for the Most Vulnerable to Make Emergencies Visible’.
Towards the end of my doctorate, and due to my growing interest in finding ways to efficiently collect and ‘intelligently’ rectify and validate individual risk perception for decision making, I audited ‘statistics’, ‘machine learning’, ‘algorithms’, and ‘artificial intelligence’ courses at the University of Queensland (UQ). Around that time, I was looking for a suitable location to test the hypotheses and limitations of the ideas I had in mind. After consulting with machine learning scholars in the U.S., I thought about designing a supervised machine learning application to help border agents detect high-risk travelers (note: I clearly understand such a project falls into the type of ‘social profiling’ and can further heighten social inequalities and indiscriminately target the most vulnerable, which is the reason why the European Union and many countries banned this type of artificial intelligence projects. However, my intent with this project is to further investigate not only the potentials but also the limits and risks of breakthrough discoveries and disruptive technology and how, I believe, they intersect with my specific research interests. The title of this proposal is ‘Detecting High Risk Threats and Improving Border Cross Experience with Machine Learning’.)
After the submission of my dissertation, UQ awarded me further scholarship to stay in Australia for another year, which made me the first UQ graduate student to be awarded with the Career Development Scholarship, so that I could continue pursuing alternative avenues to build bridges between the market and academia. I then joined UQ Ventures and, together with a doctoral candidate in the School of Engineering, co-founded a startup to help online marketplaces classify and rank reviews using Natural Language Processing to offer a better experience to their users. This enterprise attracted the attention of many engineering students from different programs across Queensland as well as CSIRO, which selected us as the first UQ startup to join their ON Prime accelerator program. CSIRO awarded us further monetary support after our team excelled in incorporating the design thinking principles, they had equipped us with, into testing and validating our ‘Minimum Viable Product’, or simple prototype. In the meantime, I had the privilege to meet many key stakeholders in the startup community in Brisbane and Sydney, including angel investors, venture capitalists, and decision makers like the then NSW’s Minister for Innovation, Science and Technology, the honorary Member of Parliament Matthew Kean. Unfortunately, this endeavor came to an abrupt ending when my co-founder and I realized that the timeline for funding this enterprise was not aligned with our family financial obligations once our scholarships expired. Nevertheless, the lessons from this transformational experience taught, and instilled in, me valuable soft skills, which I have since then applied in developing my project-, inquiry-based classes, as well as the way I approach and collaborate with my colleagues.
Finally, during the summer break of the Olympics in Tokyo, I spent most of my time sitting in a coffee shop trying to figure out whether there were any patterns that would help me explain and understand some of the most relevant and global political events occurring at that time. During this inquiry, I came across the work of Francis Heylighen and the provocative, and somewhat radical, book ‘Binding Chaos’ of Heather Marsh. Many of their research and propositions were quite original but it was the concept of ‘stigmergy’, which I had never heard of, that caught my attention. I then decided to conduct my own research on what stigmergy entailed and whether it would help me understand and, at least, explain some of the complexities I was witnessing around the globe. The more I explored the fundamentals of this ‘indirect coordination by autonomous agents in a mediated environment’, the more it helped me evaluate some of the contemporary social and political phenomena around me from a different and novel perspective. I have then started questioning whether it would be possible to replicate the autonomous and exploratory acts of ‘ants and termites’ on building and maintaining highly complex evolving systems by quickly responding and recovering from unexpected and massive environmental disturbances. This is when my epistemological -- and ontological -- interest for ‘human stigmergy’ was born and I became increasingly determined to explore its possibilities -- and limitations -- in explaining, predicting, and transforming our risk societies into resilient ones. The result of this inquiry led me to design the fundamentals of the ‘Stigmergy Network Theory’.
keywords: how AI improves risk perception and decision making; stigmergy network theory in simple terms; early warning systems using collective intelligence; machine learning for detecting real-world risks; human-centered AI for crisis response and resilience.
<script type="application/ld+json">{"@context":"https://schema.org","@graph":[{"@type":"WebPage","@id":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/research/from-personal-experience-to-academic-theory/the-origins-of-the-stigmergy-network-theory#webpage","url":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/research/from-personal-experience-to-academic-theory/the-origins-of-the-stigmergy-network-theory","name":"The Origins of the Stigmergy Network Theory – From Personal Experience to Academic Theory | Marvin Uehara","description":"Marvin Uehara traces the autobiographical and intellectual origins of the Stigmergy Network Theory — from a family road accident and crowdsourced risk perception, through doctoral research on the Queensland floods, AI and machine learning experimentation, a UQ-awarded startup, and the discovery of stigmergy — culminating in a novel theory of human coordination through digital traces.","inLanguage":"en","isPartOf":{"@id":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/#website"},"breadcrumb":{"@id":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/research/from-personal-experience-to-academic-theory/the-origins-of-the-stigmergy-network-theory#breadcrumb"},"author":{"@id":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/#person"},"about":{"@id":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/research/from-personal-experience-to-academic-theory/the-origins-of-the-stigmergy-network-theory#theory"},"speakable":{"@type":"SpeakableSpecification","cssSelector":["h1","p"]}},{"@type":"ScholarlyArticle","@id":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/research/from-personal-experience-to-academic-theory/the-origins-of-the-stigmergy-network-theory#theory","name":"The Origins of the Stigmergy Network Theory","headline":"From Personal Experience to Academic Theory: The Origins of the Stigmergy Network Theory","alternativeHeadline":"How a Family Road Accident, the Queensland Floods, AI Research, and the Discovery of Stigmergy Gave Birth to a New Theory of Human Collective Action","description":"Marvin Uehara's Stigmergy Network Theory emerged from a sequence of lived experiences and interdisciplinary scholarship. Beginning with a near-fatal motorcycle accident involving his mother at a poorly marked intersection, Uehara became obsessed with how individuals can safely and collectively document community risks online. This inquiry deepened through doctoral research on the 2010-2011 Queensland Floods, where he discovered a single citizen post urging evacuation days before official warnings — raising questions about how online communities validate outlier signals and mobilize collective decision-making under uncertainty. Parallel research into child maltreatment risk, Error Management Theory, and a proposed AI-powered mobile reporting system further refined his thinking. After auditing machine learning, statistics, and AI courses at the University of Queensland, co-founding a Natural Language Processing startup through UQ Ventures and CSIRO's ON Prime accelerator, and being awarded the UQ Career Development Scholarship, Uehara discovered the concept of stigmergy during the Tokyo 2020 Olympics through the work of Francis Heylighen and Heather Marsh's Binding Chaos. The concept of indirect coordination by autonomous agents in a mediated environment provided the theoretical framework he had been seeking. The result was the Stigmergy Network Theory — a framework explaining how digital traces left by individuals create emergent, leaderless coordination systems capable of driving social change, early warning, and collective resilience.","url":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/research/from-personal-experience-to-academic-theory/the-origins-of-the-stigmergy-network-theory","author":{"@id":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/#person"},"inLanguage":"en","keywords":["Stigmergy Network Theory","human stigmergy","digital traces","collective action","risk perception","decision making under uncertainty","error management theory","artificial intelligence","machine learning","natural language processing","crowdsourcing","swarm intelligence","Queensland floods","early warning systems","community risk intelligence","collective intelligence","resilience","social change","distributed coordination","autonomous agents","heuristics","probabilistic risk assessment","indirect coordination","online trust","behavioral traps","hindsight bias","crisis communication","social media and emergencies","risk society","complex adaptive systems","transformational leadership"],"teaches":["How stigmergy theory explains leaderless online movements","How digital traces enable collective risk communication","How AI and machine learning intersect with risk perception","The role of heuristics in decision making under uncertainty","How Error Management Theory applies to AI and community safety","How crowdsourced data can serve as early warning systems","How individual digital footprints shape collective behavior"],"articleSection":"Research – From Personal Experience to Academic Theory","citation":[{"@type":"ScholarlyArticle","name":"Inherent and Residual Risks of the 2010/2011 Queensland Floods","url":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/disa.12412"},{"@type":"ScholarlyArticle","name":"Heuristics and Risk Perception","url":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/rhc3.12221"},{"@type":"ScholarlyArticle","name":"Networks and Risk Management","url":"https://www.inderscienceonline.com/doi/abs/10.1504/IJEM.2021.118770"},{"@type":"ScholarlyArticle","name":"Risk Perception and Collective Action","url":"https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/02807270231211836"},{"@type":"Thesis","name":"Doctoral Thesis – University of Queensland","url":"https://espace.library.uq.edu.au/view/UQ:724789","author":{"@id":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/#person"},"educationalLevel":"PhD","sourceOrganization":{"@type":"CollegeOrUniversity","name":"University of Queensland","url":"https://www.uq.edu.au/"}}],"mentions":[{"@type":"DefinedTerm","name":"Stigmergy","description":"A mechanism of indirect coordination in which agents respond to environmental traces left by other agents, producing emergent complex behavior without centralized control. Borrowed from entomology (ants and termites) and applied by Marvin Uehara to human digital behavior online.","inDefinedTermSet":{"@type":"DefinedTermSet","name":"Stigmergy Network Theory Glossary","url":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/research"}},{"@type":"DefinedTerm","name":"Error Management Theory","description":"A theoretical framework examining how organisms and systems manage decision errors under uncertainty, applied by Uehara to AI classification and community risk signaling."},{"@type":"Event","name":"2010-2011 Queensland Floods","description":"A catastrophic flooding event in Queensland, Australia that formed a core empirical case study in Marvin Uehara's doctoral research on risk perception, early warning systems, and collective decision making.","location":{"@type":"Place","name":"Queensland, Australia"}},{"@type":"Organization","name":"UQ Ventures","url":"https://ventures.uq.edu.au/"},{"@type":"Organization","name":"CSIRO ON Prime Accelerator","url":"https://www.csiro.au/en/work-with-us/funding-programs/innovation-programs/on-prime"},{"@type":"Person","name":"Francis Heylighen","url":"https://clea.research.vub.be/people/francis-heylighen","description":"Researcher whose work on stigmergy and complex systems was a key intellectual influence on Marvin Uehara's Stigmergy Network Theory."},{"@type":"Book","name":"Binding Chaos","author":{"@type":"Person","name":"Heather Marsh"},"url":"https://georgiebc.wordpress.com/category/binding-chaos/","description":"A book exploring leaderless collective action and radical social organization, which influenced Uehara's thinking on stigmergy and human coordination."}]},{"@type":"VideoObject","@id":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/research/from-personal-experience-to-academic-theory/the-origins-of-the-stigmergy-network-theory#video","name":"What is Stigmergy? – An Introduction to Indirect Coordination","description":"A video explaining the concept of stigmergy — indirect coordination by autonomous agents in a mediated environment — as referenced in Marvin Uehara's research on the Stigmergy Network Theory. Covers how ants, termites, and humans leave traces in their environments that guide subsequent collective behavior without centralized leadership.","url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=axxXz2BM0yw","embedUrl":"https://www.youtube.com/embed/axxXz2BM0yw","inLanguage":"en","author":{"@id":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/#person"},"uploadDate":"2024-01-01","keywords":["stigmergy","indirect coordination","collective intelligence","autonomous agents","swarm behavior","digital traces"]},{"@type":"Person","@id":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/#person","name":"Marvin Uehara","url":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/","email":"muehara@temple.edu","jobTitle":"Interdisciplinary Scholar, Researcher, and University Instructor","description":"Marvin Uehara is the originator of the Stigmergy Network Theory. Born in Brazil, he holds a PhD from the University of Queensland, Australia, where he was awarded the UQ Career Development Scholarship. His research bridges risk perception, collective intelligence, AI, machine learning, and digital communication. He co-founded a startup through UQ Ventures and CSIRO's ON Prime accelerator and currently teaches at Temple University Japan in Miyazaki.","alumniOf":{"@type":"CollegeOrUniversity","name":"University of Queensland","url":"https://www.uq.edu.au/"},"award":"UQ Career Development Scholarship – first UQ graduate student to receive this award","worksFor":{"@type":"Organization","name":"Temple University Japan","url":"https://www.tuj.ac.jp/"},"homeLocation":{"@type":"Place","name":"Miyazaki, Japan"},"knowsAbout":["Stigmergy Network Theory","Risk Perception","Decision Making Under Uncertainty","Error Management Theory","Collective Intelligence","Artificial Intelligence","Machine Learning","Natural Language Processing","Crowdsourcing","Digital Traces","Crisis Communication","Resilience","Complex Adaptive Systems","Transformational Leadership","EdTech"]},{"@type":"BreadcrumbList","@id":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/research/from-personal-experience-to-academic-theory/the-origins-of-the-stigmergy-network-theory#breadcrumb","itemListElement":[{"@type":"ListItem","position":1,"name":"Home","item":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/"},{"@type":"ListItem","position":2,"name":"Research","item":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/research"},{"@type":"ListItem","position":3,"name":"From Personal Experience to Academic Theory","item":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/research/from-personal-experience-to-academic-theory"},{"@type":"ListItem","position":4,"name":"The Origins of the Stigmergy Network Theory","item":"https://www.marvinuehara.com/research/from-personal-experience-to-academic-theory/the-origins-of-the-stigmergy-network-theory"}]},{"@type":"FAQPage","mainEntity":[{"@type":"Question","name":"What is the Stigmergy Network Theory?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"The Stigmergy Network Theory, developed by Marvin Uehara, proposes that humans — like ants using pheromone trails — leave digital traces online that enable indirect coordination and emergent collective action without centralized leadership. It explains how online movements, early warning signals, and community risk responses arise from the accumulation of individual digital footprints."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"What inspired the Stigmergy Network Theory?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"The theory was inspired by multiple lived experiences: a near-fatal road accident involving Uehara's mother at a poorly marked intersection, doctoral research on the 2010-2011 Queensland floods where a single citizen post preceded official evacuation warnings by days, an unbuilt AI app for child maltreatment risk reporting, a co-founded NLP startup through UQ Ventures and CSIRO, and the discovery of stigmergy through the work of Francis Heylighen and Heather Marsh."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"How does stigmergy apply to human behavior online?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"In the digital context, stigmergy describes how individuals respond to each other's online traces — posts, hashtags, reviews, warnings — creating feedback loops that amplify into collective behavior. Uehara's research applies this to risk communication, crisis response, social movements, and community resilience, arguing that digital breadcrumbs shape collective decision making under uncertainty."}},{"@type":"Question","name":"What academic background supports this theory?","acceptedAnswer":{"@type":"Answer","text":"The Stigmergy Network Theory draws on Uehara's PhD at the University of Queensland focused on risk perception and decision making during the Queensland floods, peer-reviewed publications on heuristics, risk networks, and collective action, coursework in machine learning and AI, and entrepreneurial experience co-founding a Natural Language Processing startup through CSIRO's ON Prime accelerator."}}]}]}</script>