Starominski-Uehara, M. (2022). Governance in Crisis: Institutionalizing Reflective Report to Guide Decision Making Under Uncertainty. In Proceedings of the Paris Institute for Advanced Study (Vol. 16). https://paris.pias.science/article/FP_Starominski
summary by Perplexity:
The paper proposes a method called "reflective reports" to guide national leaders in making decisions under uncertainty, such as during crises like the COVID-19 pandemic. The key aspects are:
Leaders gather a small group of thoughtful advisors from different fields to provide concise recommendations in a structured narrative format.
Advisors expose the assumptions, limitations, and trade-offs of their recommendations to help leaders grasp the complexity.
The structured format of brief narratives helps leaders easily understand and remember key points before deciding, without being overwhelmed by information.
Limitations include advisors oversimplifying or missing key facts, lack of diverse perspectives, and cognitive biases of leaders.
The aim is to optimize decision-making processes under time, information and resource constraints by incorporating critical thinking and transparency about uncertainties. The paper discusses applying this approach in the context of Brazil's COVID-19 response.